Sunday, August 18, 2019
The Man I Killed, By Tim Oââ¬â¢Brien Essay -- Vietnam War
Usually when someone is murdered, people expect the murderer to feel culpable. This though, is not the case in war. When in war, a soldier is taught that the enemy deserves to die, for no other reason than that they are the nationââ¬â¢s enemy. When Tim Oââ¬â¢Brien kills a man during the Vietnam War, he is shocked that the man is not the buff, wicked, and terrifying enemy he was expecting. This realization overwhelms him in guilt. Oââ¬â¢Brienââ¬â¢s guilt has him so fixated on the life of his victim that his own presence in the storyââ¬âas protagonist and narratorââ¬âfades to the black. Since he doesnââ¬â¢t use the first person to explain his guilt and confusion, he negotiates his feelings by operating in fantasyââ¬âby imagining an entire life for his victim, from his boyhood and his family to his feeling about the war and about the Americans. In The Man I Killed, Tim Oââ¬â¢Brien explores the truth of The Vietnam War by vividly describing the dead body an d the imagined life of the man he has killed to question the morality of killing in a war that seems to have no point to him. The detailed descriptions of the dead manââ¬â¢s body show the terrible costs of the war in a physical aspect. Oââ¬â¢Brienââ¬â¢s guilt almost takes on its own rhythm in the repetition of ideas, phrases, and observations about the manââ¬â¢s body. Some of the ideas here, especially the notion of the victim being a ââ¬Å"slim, young, dainty man,â⬠help emphasize Oââ¬â¢Brienââ¬â¢s fixation on the effects of his actionââ¬âthat he killed someone who was innocent and not meant to be fighting in the war. At the same time, his focus on these physical characteristics, rather than on his own feelings, betrays his attempt to keep some distance in order to dull the pain. The long, unending sentences force the reader to read the deta... ... big deal than in helping him work through his emotions. In between the remarks from the others, Oââ¬â¢Brien sits in the inevitable silence of Vietnamââ¬âa stillness that forces one to confront the realities of war. Behind every war there is supposed to be a moralââ¬âsome reason for fighting. Unfortunately, this is often not the case. Oââ¬â¢Brien relays to the readers the truth of the Vietnam War through the graphic descriptions of the man that he killed. After killing the man Oââ¬â¢Brien was supposed to feel relief, even victory, but instead he feels grief of killing a man that was not what he had expected. Oââ¬â¢Brien is supposed to be the winner, but ends up feeling like the loser. Ironically, the moral or lesson in The Things They Carried is that there is no morality in war. War is vague and illogical because it forces humans into extreme situations that have no obvious solutions.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.